Life’s a beach, train on that AI. Photo: Andy Blackmore

I write my blog for two people, you and me. I did not, however, write it for the one thousand three hundred bots who are currently eating my site alive. Hosted mainly in Singapore and China. They are like an army of the undead, unstoppable, and they are after my brains.

It took them about six months to find the blog, and once they did, they have been feasting on my words. Every day, they return, training, learning, and trying to be like me and trying to replicate me, feeding a corpus on the corpse of my life.

Now, I have an uncanny knack for being in the right job at exactly the wrong time. I watched open-mouthed as the golden age of photojournalism was eviscerated by the digital camera, then gasped from the newsroom as journalism had its heart torn out by its nemesis, the internet, all struck down by the curse of good enough. Now, with the advent of AI and LLMs, I don’t have the breath left to scream.

I live in a dystopian version of my future I never considered, and I’m not battling robots but a mindset enabled by them, in this case, AI. The problem is that AI does not need to be better than me; it does not even need to be as good, it just needs to be free, or at least feel like it.

The concepts that once drove the creative world have been reordered and reimagined. The idea that quality would be the prime mover has vanished in a puff of logic, so dense that it has obscured the damage. AI only has to be good enough, and if good enough is free, it’s good enough.

It sounds so innocuous, but it’s every bit as world-shattering as the theory of relativity that led to the atomic bomb. It doesn’t have to beat you; it just has to be good enough, good enough for someone with a budget and a deadline. That’s the economic logic that ends careers and destroys your world.

Almost 62 and still working in journalism makes me something of a survivor. Forty years of getting on with it, and while not rich in the conventional sense, I’m a millionaire in experience and possess a wisdom born of age and life.

To the LLMs and the bots, my blog, the manifestation of my life, is just training data, free content, to be scraped at will as the machine learns to be me. It’s as fucking terrifying as “Invasion of the Bodysnatchers”.

The irony, the more I write my blog, hoping for more work as a writer, the more I dig my professional grave, as that content is scraped without my consent, used without any compensation, and ends up competing against me, all because it’s good enough and it’s free.

Four redundancies, stress and worse, an endowment mortgage shortfall, COVID wiping out my savings. Cashing in the pension to keep the house. But I’m still here. Still standing. Battered and bruised, yet I’m still writing. You see, free was never free; it came at a cost. Nothing in life is free.

But that is a writer’s burden, and that is why I write, for you, and for me, yet it’s become such a heavy load carrying all those free passengers and knowing that in doing so I am killing myself.


5 responses to “The curse of good enough”

  1. Neil Turner Avatar

    Completely agree Andy. I just turned 62 and have to change my thought processes on a regular basis to stay in the game. AI is doing damage to the world and the work that we have both lived and loved for all of those decades. I don’t have any suggestions or answers – I just wanted you to know that a real person has read what you have put your heart into and even agreed.

    1. Andy Avatar

      I know, the blog is just a way to grieve in public, so the fact that AI is scraping it all hurts, it was bad enough with my photography, but somehow it hurts more with the words, like kicking a man when he is down. Just have to keep getting up…

  2. Steve Burton Avatar

    I know the feeling.
    Looking at the Analytics for my website about 25% of my traffic comes from Singapore, a fair bit from China and about 55% from UK.

    Unless I’m using specific targeted ad campaigns on Instagram and Facebook then the figures just don’t make sense.

    It’s a double edged swoard because I’m using AI in very creative ways that I’m having to work hard to learn and understand in my photo booth business.

  3. Heathcliff Avatar
    Heathcliff

    We’re entering a frightening new reality, I agree with your observations on how digital has adversely impacted the news room .
    A friend I’ve known since my teens is currently training Ai to do his job at an engineering firm, literally teaching a bot to take his seat in the office . I genuinely fear for my children’s careers, how long will THEY last if Ai is going to devour all the white collar jobs they’ve spent years in debt laden education for ? Maybe Timothy Leary’s quote will carry more weight in the years to come as more disenfranchised citizens will want to Tune in, Turn on and ultimately Drop out . There are only so many barbers and baristas the higher street can hire

    1. Andy Avatar

      I know, I fear for the future, which given I’ve had a past is bad enough, but to be robbed of your past and future by Ai, is neither right nor fair.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *